Only half out of 100 million euros will remain
This is translation from Romanian. The original story is HERE.
The sad story about how Moldova failed to benefit from Poland’s assistance worth 100 million euros continues.
Not enough applications
The Moldovan Finance Ministry suggests re-opening negotiations with Polish authorities in order to lower the amount from 100 million euros to 50 million. The agreement which the premiers of the two countries signed in May 2014 would be extended thus until August 8, 2017.
“The Polish side has asked to consider reducing the amount of the loan given the [small] number of potential beneficiaries and the value of their projects,” says a ministerial note to the draft decision on re-negotiation of the Polish loan agreement. It exemplifies with the fact that the Finance Ministry received 23 applications for 26.6 million euros which the loan implementation unit had approved for funding.
Only 8.6 million in 30 months
"Up to this day the Moldovan Finance Ministry has approved for funding six applications for a total of 10 million euros and asked the Polish Finance Ministry to give green light to implementation and release the funds. The Polish side in turn approved five applications worth 8.6 million euros," the note reads.
Statistically, it took 30 months to see only 8.6% of the loan made available to Moldovan farmers – a clear failure for the program.
Populism to blame
Economist Viorel Chivriga of IDIS Viitorul, a respected think tank in Chisinau, blames the Moldovan government for poor negotiation skills and mismanagement of the Polish loan program.
"This loan was and still is important for the Moldovan agricultural sector. It is a big deal of money for our farmers – four times the size of the annual subsidy budget. Unfortunately there has been too much populism regarding this program and now you can see where we are," the expert said.
Mr. Chivriga established several factors that have led to the failure. One is what he called “a game with the interest rate, which was increasing and then decreasing a few times.” Another factor is “a true battle between various governmental agencies” for the right to administrate the Polish loan program.
The damages inflicted by Moldova’s failure to harvest the benefits of this program are huge, according to the expert.
"It was the money assigned for development of an important agricultural sector – the breeding sector – which has been paralyzed for years and needs large investments in order to move forward. Now it is unclear if the farmers working in this sector will ever get the money. We also realize now that the public functionaries in Moldova are unable to manage a concrete situation," Viorel Chivriga stated.
The Polish loan is a technical assistance mechanism and Moldovan applicants need to find partners in Poland in order to qualify. The biggest part of resources will remain in Poland because 60% of goods and services must be of Polish origin. The banking sector is not involved at any stage.
Under the agreement, successful Moldovan farmers from the breeding sector receive loans in the form of equipment, hardware, infrastructure elements for their projects. The resources are given for a maximum period of 12 years, with a 3-year grace time.
* * *
This article has been produced as part of the Project „Investigative reporting for transparency in public finance management and government integrity”, which is implemented by Mold-Street.com. No prior permission or copyright is applicable for republication of this piece entirely or in part and no prior agreement from Mold-Street.com is necessary to quote it.
This article has appeared thanks to the generous support of the American people via the U.S. Department of State. The opinions and conclusions herein do not necessarily reflect the stance of the Department of State or the United States Government.